Local Restaurant Guidebook
Food scene
Eating there is a special experience. Walking into the Yellow Deli, we were immediately welcomed with smiles and accommodations. The vibes of the restaurant itself are great. Feels like Woodstock, but only 5 minutes from our durham house. It’s decorated to be cozy, calming, and whimsical. The menu is small, but there is something for everyone. Everything that we ate was delicious.
Please note that on Saturday’s they are closed for Shabbat, but they are open mon thru Thursday at 10 am. If you get there at 9:45 am you are likely to be the first or second in line waiting outside the door. If you arrive at 10:05 am you are likely to expect a 30 minute wait. They open Sunday’s at noon; Their busiest days so get there at 11:50 am and wait outside or else the parking lot fills up by 12:05 and of course another 30 minute wait to be seated.
We ordered the Egg and Cheese sandwich, the Deli Waffle, and the Reuben sandwich with a side of chips. There was a little bit of a wait for the food to come to us, but all our meals came out hot and ready to eat.
They offer a whole array of eclectic tea and desserts. The carrot cake was was not only served to me with a smile, but it was the biggest slice of cake I’ve seen in a long time. The cake was super soft, tasted great, and had the perfect amount of frosting on it. I’m not a big carrot cake person and felt awkward receiving it, but I ended up enjoying it.
The Yellow Deli is a a great place to eat. Kick back, relax, and enjoy the time you spend there. The staff is friendly, everything is clean, and the food is worth the wait.
65 personas locales recomiendan
The Yellow Deli
7771 NY-81Eating there is a special experience. Walking into the Yellow Deli, we were immediately welcomed with smiles and accommodations. The vibes of the restaurant itself are great. Feels like Woodstock, but only 5 minutes from our durham house. It’s decorated to be cozy, calming, and whimsical. The menu is small, but there is something for everyone. Everything that we ate was delicious.
Please note that on Saturday’s they are closed for Shabbat, but they are open mon thru Thursday at 10 am. If you get there at 9:45 am you are likely to be the first or second in line waiting outside the door. If you arrive at 10:05 am you are likely to expect a 30 minute wait. They open Sunday’s at noon; Their busiest days so get there at 11:50 am and wait outside or else the parking lot fills up by 12:05 and of course another 30 minute wait to be seated.
We ordered the Egg and Cheese sandwich, the Deli Waffle, and the Reuben sandwich with a side of chips. There was a little bit of a wait for the food to come to us, but all our meals came out hot and ready to eat.
They offer a whole array of eclectic tea and desserts. The carrot cake was was not only served to me with a smile, but it was the biggest slice of cake I’ve seen in a long time. The cake was super soft, tasted great, and had the perfect amount of frosting on it. I’m not a big carrot cake person and felt awkward receiving it, but I ended up enjoying it.
The Yellow Deli is a a great place to eat. Kick back, relax, and enjoy the time you spend there. The staff is friendly, everything is clean, and the food is worth the wait.
Amazingly fun ambiance, and great food. Always a band, always a bonfire, outdoor dining and indoor. Such a big place never a long wait, service is not great but it makes up for it in food.
214 personas locales recomiendan
Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House
5639 NY-23Amazingly fun ambiance, and great food. Always a band, always a bonfire, outdoor dining and indoor. Such a big place never a long wait, service is not great but it makes up for it in food.
A French country bistro right in the heart of downtown Windham. We sat on the lovely terrace and enjoyed the fresh air and incredible food. Not embarrassed to admit that after tasting the homemade sorbet my son ordered, I had to order some for myself. The waitstaff were extremely attentive and kind. Has a children's' menu and for the grownups, there is a stocked bar.
71 personas locales recomiendan
Bistro Brie & Bordeaux
5386 NY-23A French country bistro right in the heart of downtown Windham. We sat on the lovely terrace and enjoyed the fresh air and incredible food. Not embarrassed to admit that after tasting the homemade sorbet my son ordered, I had to order some for myself. The waitstaff were extremely attentive and kind. Has a children's' menu and for the grownups, there is a stocked bar.
Located in downtown Windham, this diner has typical diner fare; something for everyone! Service is friendly and food is good. Bonus...it has its own parking lot!
53 personas locales recomiendan
Michael's Diner- Now Windham Diner
5339 NY-23Located in downtown Windham, this diner has typical diner fare; something for everyone! Service is friendly and food is good. Bonus...it has its own parking lot!
Great salads, burgers and traditional Irish dishes like reubens, bangers and mash, and Irish chicken curry. Located in East Durham. Homemade comfort food with an Irish flavor.
16 personas locales recomiendan
The Shamrock House
2388 NY-145Great salads, burgers and traditional Irish dishes like reubens, bangers and mash, and Irish chicken curry. Located in East Durham. Homemade comfort food with an Irish flavor.
Yummy Italian and wood-fire pizza oven. What could possibly be better than that? Another great choice in downtown Windham. Serve wine and beer.
105 personas locales recomiendan
Millrock Restaurant
5398 NY-23Yummy Italian and wood-fire pizza oven. What could possibly be better than that? Another great choice in downtown Windham. Serve wine and beer.
Very delicious take-out (only) chinese restaurant in Windham. Best Chinese Food around! This place has a very loyal following. They pride themselves on always getting your order right.
14 personas locales recomiendan
Qin Fang Garden
5448 NY-23Very delicious take-out (only) chinese restaurant in Windham. Best Chinese Food around! This place has a very loyal following. They pride themselves on always getting your order right.
Another Windham Italian favorite. In addition to the delicious food, locals love the casual atmosphere, warm bread and friendly service.
22 personas locales recomiendan
Messina's Lagriglia Ristorante
5658 NY-23Another Windham Italian favorite. In addition to the delicious food, locals love the casual atmosphere, warm bread and friendly service.
Best Chicken Parm you will find! If you're here on a Wednesday then go for Pasta Night! They offer a ton of pasta dishes, plus they always have a full-service bar.
52 personas locales recomiendan
Brandywine
11157 NY-23Best Chicken Parm you will find! If you're here on a Wednesday then go for Pasta Night! They offer a ton of pasta dishes, plus they always have a full-service bar.
There are two locations: one in Windham and one in Tannersville. Both worth the trip. Use lots of locally-produced ingredients, fresh and wonderful food, miniature goats. Plus there's fudge! The adorable shop has a Cracker Barrel Vibe, with games, toys, baked goods, candy and knick knacks of all kinds.
105 personas locales recomiendan
Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham
5510 NY-23There are two locations: one in Windham and one in Tannersville. Both worth the trip. Use lots of locally-produced ingredients, fresh and wonderful food, miniature goats. Plus there's fudge! The adorable shop has a Cracker Barrel Vibe, with games, toys, baked goods, candy and knick knacks of all kinds.
German/Swiss food. They offer different types of fondue too. We've only had the fondue specialties, but would definitely go back for it again! The apple strudel is delicious too.
11 personas locales recomiendan
Chalet Fondue
55 NY-296German/Swiss food. They offer different types of fondue too. We've only had the fondue specialties, but would definitely go back for it again! The apple strudel is delicious too.
Vesuvio in Hensonville is another delicious Italian and this one takes reservations! The meatballs are supposedly incredible!
62 personas locales recomiendan
Vesuvio
49 Co Rd 65Vesuvio in Hensonville is another delicious Italian and this one takes reservations! The meatballs are supposedly incredible!
Casual atmosphere. Pizza, soup and pasta are fan favorites. Large portions are also appreciated.
23 personas locales recomiendan
Neapolis
5330 NY-23Casual atmosphere. Pizza, soup and pasta are fan favorites. Large portions are also appreciated.
Milk run is a five minute drive from the house. Also the only place that delivers to the house. It’s a to-go deli , convenience store too. Freshly sliced cold cuts, sandwiches, wraps, eggs and more! Outdoor seating. Also has a Gas station , market with the normal merchandise.
27 personas locales recomiendan
Milk Run
3498 NY-145Milk run is a five minute drive from the house. Also the only place that delivers to the house. It’s a to-go deli , convenience store too. Freshly sliced cold cuts, sandwiches, wraps, eggs and more! Outdoor seating. Also has a Gas station , market with the normal merchandise.
What more needs to be said? Ice Cream! There's an arcade, mini golf, Subway Sandwich, and movie theater in the same building.
7 personas locales recomiendan
Carvel
11 Vets RdWhat more needs to be said? Ice Cream! There's an arcade, mini golf, Subway Sandwich, and movie theater in the same building.
Subway Sandwich shop. Also, Carvel, arcade, movie theater, and mini golf in the same place.
Subway Restaurants
11 Vets RoadSubway Sandwich shop. Also, Carvel, arcade, movie theater, and mini golf in the same place.
Windham Steakhouse. Has both steak and seafood, and a Saturday brunch. Nothing beats the fresh warm bread and incredible cocktails!
18 personas locales recomiendan
Lilly's Steaks & Cocktails
5335 New York 23Windham Steakhouse. Has both steak and seafood, and a Saturday brunch. Nothing beats the fresh warm bread and incredible cocktails!
Live music on Fridays and Saturdays. Wonderful cafe with delicious tomato soup, truffle grilled cheese and cheesy mac and cheese. Great fun and great menu.
129 personas locales recomiendan
The Windham Local
5410 NY-23Live music on Fridays and Saturdays. Wonderful cafe with delicious tomato soup, truffle grilled cheese and cheesy mac and cheese. Great fun and great menu.
Way more than just a gas station market. This eat-in or take-out market has brick oven pizza, deli sandwiches, pastries and ice cream,. Super clean, plus you can pick up lots of other supplies while you're there.
62 personas locales recomiendan
Hickory Hill Market
5200 NY-23Way more than just a gas station market. This eat-in or take-out market has brick oven pizza, deli sandwiches, pastries and ice cream,. Super clean, plus you can pick up lots of other supplies while you're there.
Located in Cairo, NY, not far from the Hannaford Supermarket. Great ambiance. Large, stocked bar, casual vibe and friendly staff. Has everything from pasta dishes and brick oven pizza, to salads and bbq pulled pork. Great place to stop if you're coming to Durham from the NYS thruway.
39 personas locales recomiendan
Barnwood
14 Deer LnLocated in Cairo, NY, not far from the Hannaford Supermarket. Great ambiance. Large, stocked bar, casual vibe and friendly staff. Has everything from pasta dishes and brick oven pizza, to salads and bbq pulled pork. Great place to stop if you're coming to Durham from the NYS thruway.
The Brussel Sprouts are the best you’ll ever have!
84 personas locales recomiendan
Jessie's Harvest House
5819 Main StThe Brussel Sprouts are the best you’ll ever have!
Now called "Modena". Newly opened Italian Restaurant across from the Greenville Drive-In movie. The margherita pizza was excellent.
26 personas locales recomiendan
Mountain View Brasserie
10697 NY-32Now called "Modena". Newly opened Italian Restaurant across from the Greenville Drive-In movie. The margherita pizza was excellent.
Used to be Charlie's but now it's Gigi's! Delicious Ice Cream with picnic tables outside. Wonderful and friendly staff. Worth the trip!
Charlie’s Angels Icecream
9495 NY-32Used to be Charlie's but now it's Gigi's! Delicious Ice Cream with picnic tables outside. Wonderful and friendly staff. Worth the trip!
Extensive wine list. The owner is so sweet and gives great recommendations. Warm and cozy atmosphere, the fire pit area is very warm under the tent and each couch has multiple folded fuzzy blankets ready to use for additional comfort.
The prices are very fair. Cordelia and her team bring service and hospitality to the next level. Friendly to new and experienced to wine and wine tasting. There’s also craft beer and ciders available for those who don’t fancy wine.
Overall a great experience- would recommend coming here to anyone!
117 personas locales recomiendan
Ze Windham Wine Bar
5369 Main StreetExtensive wine list. The owner is so sweet and gives great recommendations. Warm and cozy atmosphere, the fire pit area is very warm under the tent and each couch has multiple folded fuzzy blankets ready to use for additional comfort.
The prices are very fair. Cordelia and her team bring service and hospitality to the next level. Friendly to new and experienced to wine and wine tasting. There’s also craft beer and ciders available for those who don’t fancy wine.
Overall a great experience- would recommend coming here to anyone!
Five Furlongs Tavern is not only the closest restaurant to the vacation house (8 minute drive), but in my opinion, the best cuisine in the area. The chef, San Diego, is a highly trained chef who, I think, can beat out any five-star restaurant in New York City, but with the atmosphere of a local tavern. Everything on the menu is great. Some of the highlights are the French onion soup, the char grilled teriyaki salmon with wasabi and the roasted, garlic potatoes puree.
Five Furlongs Tavern
Five Furlongs Tavern is not only the closest restaurant to the vacation house (8 minute drive), but in my opinion, the best cuisine in the area. The chef, San Diego, is a highly trained chef who, I think, can beat out any five-star restaurant in New York City, but with the atmosphere of a local tavern. Everything on the menu is great. Some of the highlights are the French onion soup, the char grilled teriyaki salmon with wasabi and the roasted, garlic potatoes puree.